The Role of Medical Experts in Birth Injury Lawsuits

The Role of Medical Experts in Birth Injury Lawsuits

Updated November 17, 2026.

Medical experts are essential in a birth injury lawsuit. In Illinois, a family generally cannot win without them: an expert must explain the standard of care for the doctors and nurses involved, show how it was violated, and connect that violation to the child’s injury. Illinois also requires a written report from a qualified health professional before a malpractice lawsuit can proceed, under 735 ILCS 5/2-622. Later, other experts project the child’s lifetime care needs and lost earning capacity, which often make up most of the damages.

The experts in a typical birth injury case

Obstetrician or maternal-fetal medicine specialist. Reviews prenatal care, labor management and delivery decisions, such as how fetal distress was handled or whether a C-section should have been done sooner.

Labor and delivery nursing expert. Evaluates whether nurses interpreted fetal heart monitoring correctly and escalated concerns to the physician.

Neonatologist. Reviews the newborn’s resuscitation and NICU care, including whether cooling therapy was offered for a brain injury.

Pediatric neurologist and neuroradiologist. Diagnose the injury and read brain imaging to help show when and how it happened, which is often the central dispute.

Life care planner. Builds a detailed plan of the child’s future medical, therapy, equipment, housing and attendant care needs.

Economist and vocational expert. Calculate the cost of that care over the child’s life and the child’s lost earning capacity. We explain that process in our post on lost earning capacity after a child’s brain injury.

What experts must prove

Standard of care. What a reasonably careful provider in the same specialty would have done.

Breach. How the providers fell short, for example by missing signs of oxygen deprivation on the monitoring strips.

Causation. That the breach caused the injury, rather than a genetic condition, infection or another factor. Defendants often argue the injury happened before labor, so timing evidence from imaging and lab results is critical.

Damages. The full lifetime impact on the child and family.

The defense hires its own experts, and the case often comes down to whose experts are more persuasive and better supported by the records.


Illinois rules that affect experts

Before filing suit, the family’s attorney must obtain a written report from a qualified health professional stating that there is a reasonable and meritorious cause for the lawsuit. Our post on the Illinois certificate of merit explains that requirement. At trial, experts must generally practice in the same or a similar field as the defendant they are testifying about.

Birth injury claims for a child generally must be filed within eight years of the negligent act and before the child’s 22nd birthday, as explained in our post on birth injuries that are noticed later. For how these cases are valued, see birth injury settlement amounts in Illinois.


Talk to a Chicago birth injury lawyer

Phillips Law Offices represents children and families in birth injury cases across Chicago and Illinois, working with independent obstetric, nursing, neonatal and neurology experts. The consultation is free, and you pay no fee unless we recover compensation for you.

Call (312) 346-4262 or book a free consultation online.

Frequently asked questions

Why do birth injury cases need medical experts?

Experts explain the standard of care, show how it was violated and prove that the violation caused the child’s injury. Illinois juries generally cannot find malpractice without that testimony.

What kinds of experts are used in birth injury cases?

Obstetricians, labor and delivery nurses, neonatologists, pediatric neurologists and neuroradiologists for liability and causation, plus life care planners and economists for damages.

What is the Illinois certificate of merit?

A written report from a qualified health professional, required by 735 ILCS 5/2-622, stating that a malpractice case has a reasonable and meritorious basis.

How do experts prove when a birth injury happened?

By analyzing fetal heart monitoring, blood gases, Apgar scores and brain imaging patterns, which can indicate whether an injury occurred during labor and delivery or earlier.

Request a Free Consultation