Lung Cancer Misdiagnosis in Illinois: When a Missed Diagnosis Is Malpractice

Lung cancer misdiagnosis: when it is malpractice in Illinois, Phillips Law Offices

A lung cancer misdiagnosis becomes medical malpractice in Illinois when a doctor, radiologist or hospital fails to act the way a reasonably careful provider would, and that failure lets the cancer grow to a later, harder-to-treat stage. Common examples include a lung nodule on a scan that nobody followed up, a persistent cough treated as pneumonia for months without imaging, and an abnormal result that never reached the patient. Timing matters: according to the American Cancer Society, the five-year relative survival rate for non-small cell lung cancer is 67% when it is found while still localized, but 12% once it has spread to distant organs.

Not every missed cancer is malpractice. Some lung cancers are hard to see even for careful doctors. The legal question is whether the care fell below the accepted standard, and whether an earlier diagnosis would have changed the outcome.

How lung cancer gets missed

An incidental nodule is never followed up. Many lung cancers first appear by accident on a CT scan done for something else, such as an emergency room scan after a car crash or a cardiac CT. Radiologists use published guidelines, such as the Fleischner Society recommendations, to decide when a nodule needs a repeat scan. When the report recommends follow-up but nobody orders it or tells the patient, the cancer can grow unnoticed.

A radiologist misreads the image. A visible mass on a chest X-ray or CT is described as normal, or compared to the wrong prior study. Our post on misread X-ray, MRI and ultrasound malpractice covers these errors.

Symptoms are blamed on something else. A cough that will not go away, coughing up blood, chest pain, shortness of breath or unexplained weight loss is treated again and again as bronchitis, pneumonia, asthma or COPD, without imaging to rule out a tumor.

An eligible patient is never offered screening. The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force recommends a yearly low-dose CT scan for adults aged 50 to 80 who have a 20 pack-year smoking history and currently smoke or quit within the past 15 years. Failing to discuss screening with a patient who clearly qualifies can be part of a claim.

Test results fall through the cracks. A biopsy or pathology result is wrong, or an abnormal result is sent to a doctor who never acts on it and never calls the patient.

Five-year relative survival for non-small cell lung cancer is 67% when localized and 12% when distant, according to the American Cancer Society


Why the stage at diagnosis matters so much

The American Cancer Society reports these five-year relative survival rates for non-small cell lung cancer, based on people diagnosed from 2015 to 2021:

  • Localized (only in the lung): 67%
  • Regional (spread to nearby lymph nodes or structures): 40%
  • Distant (spread to other organs): 12%

Earlier-stage cancers can often be treated with surgery or targeted radiation. Later-stage cancers usually require more aggressive treatment and have worse outcomes. In a malpractice case, medical experts compare what stage the cancer was likely at when it should have been found with the stage at which it was actually diagnosed.

What you have to prove in Illinois

An Illinois medical malpractice claim generally requires proof of four things:

  1. A doctor-patient relationship that created a duty of care.
  2. A breach of the standard of care, shown through testimony from a qualified medical expert.
  3. Causation: the breach caused harm, such as the cancer progressing to a later stage.
  4. Damages, such as more extensive treatment, lost income, pain and suffering, or a shortened life.

Before filing, Illinois requires an attorney to attach an affidavit and a report from a qualified health professional stating that the case has merit, under 735 ILCS 5/2-622. Our post on the Illinois certificate of merit explains this step.

Loss of chance

Defendants often argue that the patient would have died anyway. Illinois allows recovery when a doctor’s negligence reduced a patient’s chance of survival or a better outcome. In Holton v. Memorial Hospital (1997), the Illinois Supreme Court held that a plaintiff can recover when negligence increased the risk of harm or lessened the effectiveness of treatment, even if the chance of survival was already below 50%.

No cap on damages

Illinois does not cap damages in medical malpractice cases. The Illinois Supreme Court struck down the most recent cap in Lebron v. Gottlieb Memorial Hospital (2010).


Deadlines for a lung cancer misdiagnosis claim

Under 735 ILCS 5/13-212(a), a medical malpractice claim generally must be filed within two years of when you knew, or reasonably should have known, about the injury and that it may have been caused by negligence. No claim can be filed more than four years after the act or omission, with limited exceptions such as fraudulent concealment. Because a missed cancer is often discovered months or years later, these deadlines need careful review. Our post on the discovery rule in Illinois medical malpractice walks through how they work.

If a family member died, the family may bring a wrongful death claim under 740 ILCS 180 and a survival claim for the losses the person suffered before death. Those claims have their own deadline rules.

What to do if you think lung cancer was missed

  • Request copies of every imaging report and image, not just the summaries. The radiology report often contains the follow-up recommendation that was ignored.
  • Write down a timeline: when symptoms started, each visit, what you were told and when tests were done.
  • Keep your patient portal messages and any letters about test results.
  • Focus on treatment first. A lawyer can gather records while you work with your oncology team.

For more on missed and delayed cancer diagnoses in general, see our cancer misdiagnosis guide and our post on how to sue a doctor for misdiagnosis.


Talk to a Chicago medical malpractice lawyer

Phillips Law Offices has handled medical malpractice cases in Chicago and across Illinois for decades, including failure-to-diagnose claims. We work with radiologists, oncologists and other experts to determine whether an earlier diagnosis would have made a difference. The consultation is free, and you pay no fee unless we recover compensation for you.

Call (312) 346-4262 or book a free consultation online.

Frequently asked questions

Can I sue for a missed lung cancer diagnosis in Illinois?

Yes, if a provider failed to meet the standard of care and the delay caused harm, such as the cancer advancing to a later stage. A qualified medical expert must support the claim before it is filed.

What is the most common way lung cancer is missed?

Common examples include a lung nodule seen on a scan that is never followed up, a misread chest X-ray or CT, and symptoms like a persistent cough treated without imaging.

What if the cancer would have been serious anyway?

Illinois recognizes loss of chance. Under Holton v. Memorial Hospital (1997), you can recover if negligence reduced the chance of survival or a better outcome, even if that chance was below 50%.

How long do I have to file a lung cancer misdiagnosis lawsuit?

Generally two years from when you knew or should have known of the injury and its possible negligent cause, and no more than four years after the error, with limited exceptions.

Request a Free Consultation