Can a Business Be Liable for an Assault in Its Parking Lot in Illinois?

Attacked in a parking lot: when the business is liable under Illinois negligent security law, Phillips Law Offices

Yes, in Illinois a business can be held liable when a customer is assaulted in its parking lot, but not in every case. The person who committed the attack is always responsible. The business is responsible too only if the attack was reasonably foreseeable and the business failed to take reasonable steps to prevent it, such as fixing broken lighting or acting on earlier incidents. Lawyers call these negligent security claims.

Why a business can be responsible for someone else’s crime

As a general rule, Illinois does not make people responsible for protecting others from criminals. The law makes exceptions for a few “special relationships,” and one of them is the relationship between a business and the customers it invites onto its property. The Illinois Supreme Court reaffirmed those special relationships in Marshall v. Burger King Corp., 222 Ill. 2d 422 (2006): common carrier and passenger, innkeeper and guest, business and invitee, and a person who voluntarily takes custody of another.

Inside that relationship, a business owes its customers reasonable care, including protection against harm from third parties that the business could reasonably foresee. A store, restaurant, hotel or parking garage does not have to guarantee nobody will ever be hurt. It has to act like a reasonable business would, given what it knew or should have known about the risk.

The Illinois Premises Liability Act, 740 ILCS 130, sets the broader duty of reasonable care owed to lawful visitors. Our guide to the key legal elements of premises liability walks through the basics.

Under Marshall v. Burger King (Ill. 2006), a business owes its customers protection from foreseeable harm by third parties


Foreseeability is the heart of the case

Almost every negligent security case turns on one question: should the business have seen this coming?

Prior incidents are the strongest evidence. If there had been robberies or car break-ins in the same parking lot, and the business knew or should have known about them, a later attack is much easier to call foreseeable. Courts look at how similar and how recent the earlier incidents were. In Rowe v. State Bank of Lombard, 125 Ill. 2d 203 (1988), the Illinois Supreme Court found a violent attack in an office building foreseeable based on earlier burglaries and the landlord’s knowledge that master keys were unaccounted for, even though none of the earlier incidents were violent.

Other facts can matter as well. A business may have received complaints from customers or employees. Police may have been called to the property, or the business may have warned its own staff about the area at night. A lawyer will usually request police call records for the address and the business’s own incident logs early in the case.


What reasonable security can look like

The law does not require a business to post armed guards. What is reasonable depends on the risk. Common failures in these cases include broken or dim parking lot lighting that was reported and never fixed, along with security cameras that were not working or not monitored.

Broken garage gates and locks come up often. So does a security patrol that was cut back after the business already knew there was trouble.

When a business promised security

A separate rule applies when a business or landlord takes on security voluntarily. Under the voluntary undertaking doctrine, which the court applied in Rowe, a party that chooses to provide security measures must carry them out with reasonable care. A business that advertises a monitored, well-lit garage or hires a security company can be liable if it does that job negligently and the negligence leads to an attack.

Landlords are treated a little differently from stores and restaurants. A landlord generally has no duty to protect tenants from crime, but the voluntary undertaking rule and the landlord’s control over common areas can create one. Our post on when a landlord can be held liable for tenant injuries covers that side of the law.


Who can be held responsible

The attacker is responsible, but often cannot pay a judgment. The civil claim against the property is usually where real compensation comes from.

That claim can run against the business that invited you onto the property, along with the owner of the lot if a different company owns it. A property management company that controls maintenance and security can share the blame. A private security contractor that was supposed to patrol the lot can too.

Illinois uses modified comparative fault under 735 ILCS 5/2-1116. A victim of a violent crime is rarely found to share fault for being attacked, but the defense may still try to argue it.


What you can recover

A negligent security claim can cover medical bills and lost income, along with pain and suffering and the emotional effects of the attack, which can last long after physical injuries heal. If the attack was fatal, the family can bring a wrongful death claim under the Illinois Wrongful Death Act, 740 ILCS 180.

Separately from a lawsuit, victims of violent crime in Illinois may be eligible for help through the Illinois Crime Victims Compensation Program, run by the Illinois Attorney General’s office. It has its own requirements and deadlines, including reporting the crime to police.


What to do after an attack in a parking lot

Get medical care and report the crime to the police. A police report is important for a criminal case, and it is the first official record of where and how the attack happened.

Report the incident to the business in writing too, and ask that its video footage be preserved. Many camera systems record over themselves within days or weeks, so this step cannot wait. If you can, take photos of the lighting and the spot where it happened, plus anything broken, such as a gate or a dark light pole.

Write down the names of employees or witnesses who helped you. Do not give a recorded statement to the business’s insurer before you talk to a lawyer. Our guide on what to do right after a premises liability injury has more.


Illinois deadlines

Most personal injury claims in Illinois must be filed within two years (735 ILCS 5/13-202), and a wrongful death claim generally within two years of the death (740 ILCS 180/2). If the property belongs to a city or park district, the deadline against that public body is usually one year, and it may have immunities private businesses do not. Our guide to the Illinois personal injury statute of limitations covers the exceptions.


Talk to a Chicago negligent security lawyer

Phillips Law Offices handles premises liability cases across Chicago and Illinois, including claims against businesses and property owners that failed to keep visitors safe. We move quickly to preserve video and records before they disappear. The consultation is free, and you pay no fee unless we recover compensation for you.

Call (312) 346-4262 or book a free consultation online. For other hazards guests face on business property, see our post on Legionnaires’ disease from a hotel hot tub.

Frequently asked questions

Can I sue a store if I was attacked in its parking lot?

Possibly. Illinois treats the relationship between a business and its customers as a special relationship, so a business can be liable if the attack was reasonably foreseeable and it failed to take reasonable security steps. Earlier incidents on the property are often the key evidence.

What is a negligent security claim?

It is a premises liability claim against a property owner or business whose inadequate security allowed a foreseeable crime to happen. The attacker is still responsible, but the property owner can share responsibility for its own failures.

Does the business have to have security guards?

Not necessarily. What is reasonable depends on the risk. For many properties it means working lights and cameras, and acting on known problems. A business that promises security, such as a monitored garage, must provide it with reasonable care.

What if my landlord’s parking lot was the problem?

Illinois landlords generally have no duty to protect tenants from crime, but they can be liable if they voluntarily provided security and did it negligently, or if they failed to maintain common areas they control. The facts matter a great deal.

How long do I have to file a negligent security claim in Illinois?

Generally two years from the attack, or two years from the date of death for a wrongful death claim. Claims against a public body usually have a one-year deadline. Ask the business to preserve video right away, because footage can be lost within days.

Request a Free Consultation